Foreign Office Defends Pakistan’s Legal System Amid International Criticism Over Military Court Sentences

The Foreign Office of Pakistan has responded to statements by the United States, the United Kingdom, and the European Union concerning the military court sentences handed down to individuals involved in the May 9 incidents. The spokesperson affirmed that Pakistan’s legal system aligns with international agreements and human rights obligations.

Pakistan’s Position

The Foreign Office stated:

• Pakistan is committed to upholding its international human rights obligations.
• The country’s legal framework incorporates provisions from international treaties on civil and political rights.
• Provisions for judicial review by superior courts are embedded in Pakistan’s legal system.
• Military court decisions are made under laws passed by the parliament and comply with constitutional requirements.

US Concerns

The US State Department expressed:

• Serious concerns over military tribunals sentencing civilians involved in the May 9 protests.
• The lack of adherence to principles of fair trial in such proceedings.
• A call for ensuring justice and transparency in the judicial process.

EU’s Reaction

The European Union issued a statement:

• Highlighting concerns over military court decisions involving civilians, terming them violations of international agreements.
• Urging Pakistan to safeguard the rights of its citizens and ensure fair trials.

UK’s Response

The UK Foreign Office criticized:

• The use of military courts for trying civilians, citing a lack of transparency and independent oversight.
• Raised concerns about the implications of such practices on the justice system’s integrity.

Pakistan’s Rebuttal

In response, the Foreign Office emphasized:

• Decisions by military courts are in line with Pakistan’s constitution and legal system.
• Human rights and fundamental freedoms are fully guaranteed under the country’s laws.

The debate over military courts in Pakistan highlights a broader tension between domestic legal frameworks and international human rights expectations. While Pakistan maintains its stance, the international community continues to stress the importance of transparent and fair judicial practices.